Erik goes two for three, Bucky goes home.
A Queen medley by the top 8, a series of interviews with folks back home, and three songs from the bottom three: Bucky, Ace, and Elliott. That’s how Fox filled up an hour to tell us that Bucky is going home. I had him picked as number seven of eight. Not too bad. Simon got it wrong, too, as I predicted.
So how am I doing over the last two weeks compared to the other American Idol pundits? Let’s see.
| Pundit | Bottom Three Results | Bottom One Results |
| Erik J. Heels | 5 for 6 | 0 for 2 |
| Various and Sundry » American Idol | 4 for 6 | 1 for 1 |
| Reality TV Magazine | 4 for 6 | 1 for 2 |
| The Woes and the Prose of an American Idol Junkie | 4 for 6 | 0 for 2 |
| American Idol Season 5 Blog | 3 for 6 | 0 for 2 |
| Vote For The Worst | 2 for 3 | 1 for 1 |
| Simon Cowell | NA | 1 for 2 |
Next week: standards (and more?) from Rod Stewart.
