* Red Sox Fire Manager John Farrell

Controversial manager leaves a mixed legacy.

[This article, written 09/12/16, is a parody. But it is also a prediction. No manager lasts forever. Farrell will eventually get fired. And when he does, the Red Sox front office will release a press release more or less like this one. Just change the date. Those, like me, who support the #FireFarrell movement, can see the 2016 season predictably ending in a train wreck, long before said train wreck actually occurs. Math, logic, season ticket holders, and Red Sox fans who actually want the team to win all point to #FireFarrell. Yet, inexplicably, in a sport dominated by the rule of meritocracy, the remarkably mediocre Farrell has been given a lifetime pass. I can think of no other player or manger in my lifetime who has been given this treatment. Maybe its time for new ownership as well.]

11/04/2016 5:17 PM ET

BOSTON, MA – After a devastating elimination in the 2016 postseason, and in what turned out to be the final season in the career of Red Sox legend David Ortiz, the Boston Red Sox and now former manager John Farrell have parted ways.

“John Farrell was just what the doctor ordered when he came here,” said Chairman Tom Werner, who made the announcement. “He took over a clubhouse not known for its discipline and brought unity and an atmosphere of winning. He successfully read the personality of our players and led them in an intense, sustained competition from which they never quit.”

The Red Sox will interview multiple candidates, including minority candidates, for the open managerial job. Current bench coach Torey Lovullo, who excelled as interim manager at the conclusion of the 2015 season, is considered to be the leading candidate.

“We thank John for the many contributions he made and for the energy he brought each day,” said President Sam Kennedy. “He is a baseball man through and through.”

Boston Red Sox manager John Farrell gestures from the dugout before playing against the Toronto Blue Jays in a baseball game in Toronto, Friday, April 5, 2013. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Nathan Denette)
Boston Red Sox manager John Farrell gestures from the dugout before playing against the Toronto Blue Jays in a baseball game in Toronto, Friday, April 5, 2013. (AP Photo/The Canadian Press, Nathan Denette)

Farrell, after all is said and done, leaves a complicated and mixed legacy with the Red Sox. As a player from 1987 to 1996, Farrell was plagued with injuries while amassing a lifetime win-loss record of 36-46. As a pitching coach for the Red Sox from 2007-2010, Farrell had success with young pitchers, especially Jon Lester, and helped the Red Sox to the 2007 World Series championship.

As a manager with the Toronto Blue Jays from 2011 to 2012, Farrell’s win-loss record was 154-170 (.475). Despite having a losing record in Toronto, Farrell was hired by the Red Sox and managed them for four seasons from 2013 to 2016. The 2013 season was the high point, as a team of overachievers played above their lifetime averages and unexpectedly brought home the third World Series championship in 10 years for the Red Sox.

The 2014 and 2015 seasons were both complete disasters, with the Red Sox finishing in last place both seasons. And while the Red Sox had a potent offense and high hopes for the 2016 season, they largely underperformed both individually, compared to lifetime averages, and as a team, comparing their actual win-loss record to their expected win-loss (XWL) record.

The way the 2016 season ended was both devastating to Red Sox fans and unacceptable to the Red Sox front office. As such, Farrell was let go.

Media and fans alike complained that Farrell did not have a strong enough bullpen to win the World Series. In fact, general manager Dave Dombrowski’s Achilles heel has been his inability to develop a winning bullpen. However, when you look at the data, you can see that Farrell rarely gave his relievers a chance at a clean inning, instead routinely leaving starting pitchers in too long. Had Farrell routinely taken pitchers out between innings after they had thrown 90+ pitches, the starters would have thrown fewer pitches, the starters would have been been more rested for their next start, and the relievers would have been put in better positions to succeed.

“This season was certainly a difficult and draining one for him and for us,” said President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski. “Ultimately, we decided that there were certain things that needed to be done that John couldn’t do after four years here, and that this team would benefit from hearing a new voice. That said, his next team will benefit more than it knows from hearing John’s voice. I will miss seeing John every day in the manager’s office, and I wish him and his family nothing but the best in their next chapter.”

The Elias Sports Bureau reports that no MLB manger made more on-the-mound pitching changes than Farrell during the 2016 season. This resulted in overworking both the starters and the relievers. So it’s not that the Red Sox bullpen was beleaguered, rather that Farrell’s mismanagement of the entire roster routinely put players – and ultimately the team – in a position to fail. Not surprisingly, the 2016 Red Sox also led the league in inherited runs scored.

“Sports franchises often have difficult decisions to make regarding great individuals,” said Principal Owner John Henry. “Sometimes these moves are popular; sometimes they are not. We have an obligation, however, to keep our eye on the ball and stay focused on how to achieve a World Championship for the people of Boston and New England. There is no doubt that John Farrell was a great asset to the club in his four years of managing, and we wish him nothing but the best.”

The club has set no timetable for the search for and hiring of a new manager.


Boston Red Sox
Fenway Park
4 Yawkey Way
Boston, MA 02215
Tel: 617-226-6000

Principal Owner: John W. Henry
Chairman: Thomas C. Werner
President: Sam Kennedy
President of Baseball Operations: Dave Dombrowski
President/CEO Emeritus: Larry Lucchino

Related Press Releases

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

One Reply to “* Red Sox Fire Manager John Farrell”

  1. Postscript:

    * Red Sox Fire Manager John Farrell (2017-10-11)

    * Red Sox dismiss Farrell after five seasons (2017-10-11)
    Decision to replace skipper, who won World Series, was a tough one, says Dombrowski.

    * Statement From John Farrell (2017-10-11)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *